XII. Supporting Biodiversity and Plant Justice through Varying Indigenous Concepts of Covenants of Reciprocity

Session Type: 
Oral
Session Date and Time: 
Thursday, 22 May, 2025 - 15:45 to 17:00
Primary Organizer/Session Chair: 
Pamela Spalding
Organization/Affiliation: 
Syracuse University (Center for Global Indigenous Cultures)
Names of Additional Organizers: 

Nancy Turner
Isabelle Maurice-Hammond

This session explores how various examples of Indigenous land stewardship throughout North America provides a powerful example through which to de-center human exceptionalism in resource management and environmental governance. Unlike western ecology, Indigenous concepts of biodiversity usually acknowledge relationality through kinship and obligations between humans, the sacred world, plants, animals, fungi, and abiotic factors. This concept of biodiversity opens space for the emerging field of plant justice and the acceptance of plants as legal ‘persons. It envisions justice for the land involving an agreement between land and people that is simultaneously ecological and cultural. It recognizes that ecological integrity arises from reciprocal exchanges (what systems ecologists might call negative feedback loops or the biogeochemical give and take among members of an ecosystem) that produce biodiversity and ecological stability. It emphasizes moving forward from a widely held understanding amongst many Indigenous peoples of kinship with an animate and spiritual more than human world that is eloquently articulated in distant time stories where humans are surrounded by and interact with intelligences other than that of humans. Following from participatory action methodology this approach suggests that we apprentice to both Indigenous knowledge holders and the plants themselves so that through empathy and learning we might better understand the gifts plants have to offer and what legal dignity looks like for humans, plants and ecosystems.

Presentations

Abstract
15:45
Presentation Format: 
Oral (in-person)
Author(s):
Baker
, Janelle - Athabasca University

In what is now known as northern Alberta, Northern Bush Crees, who tend to the landscape with ancient and adaptive reciprocal traditions, are asked to quantify and justify their traditional land use through the consultation process with government and corporations who actively extract natural resources from Treaty No. 8 territory. One of many problems that arise from consultation is that many of the cultural keystone plants for Northern Bush Crees are not charismatic, or rare species for Settlers. So, when communities try to protect such plants, they are unsuccessful because the plants are commonly found throughout the Boreal Forest. Many of the same plants, which are used for food and medicine, are now being sprayed with glyphosate by logging companies during the reforestation process. This paper will bring attention to some of these cultural keystone plants that are abundant in Boreal Forests, and the processes that protect and threaten them.

16:00
Presentation Format: 
Oral (in-person)
Author(s):
Maurice-Hammond
, Isabelle - UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA

Estuarine root gardens are Indigenous plant stewardship landscapes on the Pacific Northwest Coast of North America. As “living archaeological sites,” these places often still contain large quantities of traditionally managed plant foods (namely, Pacific silverweed (Argentina egedii) and springbank clover (Trifolium wormskioldii), with features of past caretaking still present even a century after the cessation of active caretaking practices. As such, they represent import nexus points of connection with descent communities, with high potential for eco-cultural restoration. Using a “Walking on Two Legs approach” (as originally articulated by the Stk’emlúpsemc te Secwépemc Nation), this paper suggests a methodology for identifying estuarine root gardens that may no longer be known by descent communities, thus re-inserting them within broader cultural landscapes and supporting Indigenous sovereignty.

16:15
Presentation Format: 
Oral (in-person)
Author(s):
Spalding
, Pamela

In the current precarious environment of remnant forests and intense industrial development, changing world climate patterns, and uncertain political and economic institutions, how can we better examine plant justice and human responsibilities to the more than human world through western and Indigenous frameworks of law and justice? My research explores why Indigenous long-term relationships with plants receive little attention in Canadian law and governance. Even though the use and management of native plants is a foundation of Indigenous cultural and legal practice, these important relationships are generally overlooked in legislation, case law, environmental assessments, and modern treaty negotiations. Using examples from Canadian law and Native American tribal court law, I will explore the potential and challenges of defining legal dignity for plants from the perspective of covenants of reciprocity with the humans whom they stand in relation.

16:30
Presentation Format: 
Oral (virtual)
Author(s):
Turner
, Nancy - University of Victoria

Humans cannot survive without plants. As well as providing the oxygen we breathe, plants have contributed to people’s cultural and linguistic diversity and richness. Plants can readily survive without humans; yet, many humans consider ourselves to be greatly superior to plants, fungi, and all other lifeforms. We have become separated from other species and have moved away from our ancestral teachings of humility and appreciation for our non-human relations. We need to reconsider our human-centricity and recognize our total dependence on the earth’s other lifeforms. We have neglected their needs at our peril. Here I provide some examples of our dependence on our non-human relations, through “Five F’s”: Foliage, Flowers, Fruit, Forests, and Fungi, with examples of recognition of this dependence from Indigenous Peoples’ cultural practices and lifeways in Northwestern North America.

16:45
Presentation Format: 
Oral (in-person)
Author(s):
Teixidor-Toneu
, Irene
Fernández-Llamazares
, Àlvaro
Alvarez Abel
, Ricardo
Batdelger
, Gantuya
Bell
, Elicia
Caillon
, Sophie
Cantor
, Mauricio
Correia
, Joel
Díaz
, Sandra
Fisk
, Jonathan
Greene
, Alexander
Greening
, Spencer
Hoyte
, Simon
Kalle
, Raivo
Loayza
, Gabriela
Mattalia
, Giulia
Montufar
, Rommel
Ojeda
, Jaime
Phatthanaphraiwan
, Suwichan
Vaccaro
, Ismael
Ban
, Natalie

In the context of climate change, biodiversity decline, and social injustice, reciprocity emerges as a way of living and being in this world that holds transformative potential. Concepts of reciprocity vary and are enacted in specific cultural practices grounded in Indigenous and local knowledge systems. This editorial synthesises first-hand evidence of how practising reciprocity can result in positive reciprocal contributions between people and nature. It also offers a theoretical justification of why considering reciprocity can lead to more equitable, inclusive, and effective conservation and sustainability policy and practices, contributing to curving the colonial baggage of academic inquiry and development action. Nurturing relations between people, especially academics, and Indigenous Peoples and local communities, is a necessary first step to identifying pathways whereby living in harmony with nature can be achieved.